bc-ontologyGovernments, institutions, geography and law
Pre-release: this release has not been published. Identifiers are permanent; descriptions may still change.

source excerpt from https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2025/09/09/25-146.pdf

https://ontology.bommaritollc.com/id/01a136d7-e8f1-76e7-9247-7cb1a4cfc679
oa:SpecificResource
Download TurtleJSON-LDN-TriplesMarkdown
Cite this
source excerpt from https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2025/09/09/25-146.pdf. bc-ontology, release 0.1.0-rc38, 2026-10-21. https://ontology.bommaritollc.com/id/01a136d7-e8f1-76e7-9247-7cb1a4cfc679

Elsewhere

Facts

adms:identifier
oa:bodyValue
{"legal_state":"unknown","passage":{"end_byte":23938,"instrument_iri":"https://ontology.bommaritollc.com/id/01a136d6-363b-71d6-9e27-83cfafd5f5eb","original_sha256":"f3fcd21968837fee4eb48d7023b421d059e116003281bdad6762652452bf3eed","parsed_text_sha256":"6cc2f164490b97f46d3273580c172ae6a0bd911623b5126454625c468838e44c","source_url":"https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2025/09/09/25-146.pdf","start_byte":11947},"policy":"retained-legal-source-passage-v1","quote":"“Approximately 95 percent of 13- to 17-year-olds, inclusive,\n\nsay that they use at least one social media platform, and more\n\nthan one-third report using social media almost constantly.”\n\nId. § 1. So California aims to reduce the “significant risk of\n\nharm to the mental health and well-being of children and\n\nadolescents” posed by “the algorithmic delivery of content”\n\non online platforms, which the California legislature\n\nconsidered “addictive.” Id.\n\nThe Act broadly regulates social media offerings to\n\nminors in California. Without parental consent, the Act\n\n(1) restricts minors’ access to algorithmic feeds through its\n\npersonalized-feeds provisions and (2) restricts certain\n\nplatform design features through its default-settings\n\nprovisions. It also (3) mandates that platforms institute yet\u0002\n\nunknown age-verification procedures (to be announced\n\nbefore 2027).\n\nThe Act regulates many websites that use personalized\n\nfeeds to serve up content to users. Those p personalized-feeds\n\nrestrictions make it u unlawful—absent parental permission—n—\n\nfor websites to provide “addictive feed[s]” to minors. Cal.\n\n10 NETCHOICE, LLC V. BONTA\n\n\nHealth & Safety Code § 27001(a); see also id.\n\n§ 27002(b)(2), (b)(4). The law is mainly directed at social\n\nmedia platforms—m—meaning internet-based services or\n\napplications that “connect users in order to allow users to\n\ninteract socially with each other” through content and posts\n\ncreated by networked profiles. Cal. Bus. & Profsfs. Code\n\n§ 22675(f); see also Cal. Health & Safety Code\n\n§ 27000.5(b)(1). But the Act also covers any website or\n\nonline service that “provides users with an addictive feed as\n\na significant part” of its service—regardless of whether that\n\nservice qualifies as a social media platform. Cal. Health &\n\nSafety Code § 27000.5(b)(1).\n\nThe Act’s central coverage definition describes\n\n“addictive feed” as any part of an online service or mobile\n\napplication in which media “generated or shared by users\n\nare, either concurrently or sequentially, recommended,\n\nselected, or prioritized for display” based “on information\n\nprovided by the user, or otherwise associated with the user\n\nor the user’s device.” Id. § 27000.5(a). As the state’s\n\nAttorney General puts it: An addictive feed consists of\n\nmedia shared by other users in which that media is shown to\n\na user based on the user’s unique information and online\n\nactivity. This means that, with some exceptions, covered\n\nplatforms cannot use any information provided by minor\n\nusers to decide what content to show them1 Cf. id.\n\n\n.\n\n(enumerating seven exceptions); id. § 27000.5(b)(2) (two\n\nadditional exceptions).\n\n1 One such exception is of particular concern here. The Act excludes\n\nwebsites “for which interactions between users are limited to commercial\n\ntransactions or to consumer reviews of products, sellers, services, events,\n\nor places, or any combination thereof.” Cal. Health & Safety Code\n\n§ 27000.5(b)(2)(A).\n\nNETCHOICE, LLC V. BONTA 11\n\n\nRegulating minors’ access to personalized feeds is the\n\nAct’s pièce de résistance. But it attacks the problem of\n\nminors’ social media addiction in other ways, too.\n\nCalifornia seeks to defang social media sites by regulating\n\nsome design features and functionalities that it views as\n\nmaking these platforms especially addictive, targeting a\n\nseries of default settings the Act imposes on minors.\n\nTwo default settings are at issue. First, covered web\n\nplatforms may not show minors how many likes, shares, or\n\nother forms of feedback a post has received within a\n\npersonalized recommendation feed. Id. § 27002(b)(3).\n\nSecond, covered platforms must make minors’ accounts\n\nprivate, which means their posts are visible only to friends\n\non the platform. Id. § 27002(b)(5).\n\nAll these restrictions—the personalized-feeds\n\nrestrictions and the default settings—can be bypassed with\n\nparental consent. See id. §§ 27001(a)(2), (b), 27002. So\n\nfamilies can opt out of the Act’s new regulatory regime if\n\nthey do not share California’s views about the risks of\n\ninternet addiction. California wants to know how often\n\nparents t take this route: Covered companies m must file annual\n\nreports showing how many minors use their services and\n\nhow many of those minors’ parents opted out. Id. § 27005.\n\nAll of this raises the question: What if a company does\n\nnot know how old its users are? Until 2027, covered\n\nplatforms need only apply the Act’s restrictions to users that\n\nthey know are minors. Id. § 27001(a), 27002(a). That\n\nchanges on January 1, 2027, when companies will have to\n\napply the Act’s restrictions to all users, unless the company\n\nhas “reasonably determined” a user is an adult. Id. The\n\nAttorney General of California m must p promulgate regulations\n\nbefore January 1, 2027, that define platforms’ age-\n\n12 NETCHOICE, LLC V. BONTA\n\n\nverification obligations. Id. § 27006(b). What those\n\nregulations will look like—and what platforms will have to\n\ndo to comply—y—is unknown.\n\nB\n\nEnter NetChoice, an internet trade association. Its\n\nmembers include Google (which owns and operates\n\nYouTube), Meta (proprietor of Facebook and Instagram),\n\nNextdoor, Pinterest, and X (formerly Twitter). Each of these\n\nmembers owns a platform that allows users to create a\n\nprofile, connect with other user profiles, and post content.\n\nAnd each employs a recommendation algorithm.\n\nIn NetChoice’s view, the Act unconstitutionally limits\n\nthese members’ ability to speak to minors (via personalized\n\nrecommendation algorithms), impedes minors’ ability to\n\naccess speech or speak publicly (via accounts not in private\n\nmode), and deters adults from accessing companies’ speech\n\n(by requiring them to first prove that they are adults). So\n\nNetChoice sued and sought a preliminary injunction. It\n\nargues that the Act is unconstitutional, both facially, and as\n\napplied to its members. It also argues that some of the Act’s\n\nlanguage is void for vagueness.\n\nThe district court granted in part and denied in part\n\nNetChoice’s motion for a preliminary injunction. See\n\nNetChoice v. Bonta, 761 F. Supp. 3d 1202, 1232 (N.D. Cal.\n\n2024). The district court preliminarily enjoined California\n\nfrom enforcing two of the Act’s provisions: the restriction\n\non sending minors notifications and the requirement that\n\ncompanies annually disclose the number of minors that use\n\ntheir services. Id. at 1227–30. Because California did not\n\nappeal those issues, they are not before us. Instead, we focus\n\non the provisions of the Act that the district court left in\n\nplace.\n\nNETCHOICE, LLC V. BONTA 13\n\n\nFirst, the district court concluded that NetChoice’s\n\nchallenge to the age-verification requirements was not ripe.\n\nIt concluded that courts must wait until we know what the\n\nAttorney General’s chosen regulatory regime will look like\n\nbefore we can decide how much speech might be affected2\n\n\n.\n\nId. at 1211–19. In other words, further factual development\n\nis needed to determine what kind of constitutional burden the\n\nAct creates for NetChoice members and the broader\n\npopulation. Id.\n\nNext, the district court decided that it could not\n\nadjudicate NetChoice’s facial challenges to the\n\npersonalized-feed provisions because there was not an\n\nadequate record to decide the scope of the Act’s coverage—\n\nincluding how much of the coverage would be\n\nunconstitutional—across the entire internet. Id. at 1218–23.\n\nIn doing so, the district court assumed that not all\n\npersonalized recommendation algorithms raised the same\n\nFirst Amendment concerns; if an algorithm “respond[s]\n\nsolely to how users act online,” the district court doubted that\n\nit is expressive. Id. at 1220–21 (quotation omitted). Nor\n\nwould the regulation of personalized algorithms necessarily\n\nburden users’ speech rights, either, the district court\n\nconcluded. See id.\n\nAs to the Act’s other provisions, the court concluded that\n\nthe Act’s central coverage definition—n—w—which defines\n\naddictive feeds—w—was not content based, a and d decided t that the\n\n2 This relies on the assumption that some age-verification methods might\n\nraise constitutional concerns, while others might not. The district court\n\nopined that the regulations may require age-estimation tools “that run in\n\nthe background and require no user input,” finding that such tools existed\n\nand would be feasible. NetChoice, 761 F. Supp. 3d at 1215–16.\n\n14 NETCHOICE, LLC V. BONTA\n\n\nlike-count and private-mode default settings passed\n\nconstitutional muster. Id. at 1225–26, 1228.\n\nThe district court did not separately consider\n\nNetChoice’s as-applied challenges to m many provisions of the\n\nAct. See id. at 1230. It decided that doing so would be\n\nduplicative of the facial challenges. Id. It separately\n\nconsidered the as-applied challenge to the personalized-feed\n\nrestrictions, concluding that NetChoice lacked associational\n\nstanding because the as-applied challenges for “each\n\nseparate NetChoice member” require their “own ‘ad hoc\n\nfactual inquiry.’” Id. at 1230–31. To adjudicate these\n\nclaims, NetChoice members needed to participate\n\nindividually in the lawsuit to discover “how each of those\n\nmembers’ feeds work.” Id. at 1231.\n\nFinally, the district court concluded that the Act’s terms\n\nwere not void for vagueness, and that facially\n\nunconstitutional provisions were severable. See id. at 1231–\n\n32.\n\nNetChoice appealed. We issued a stay preventing\n\nCalifornia from enforcing any aspect of the Act until we\n\nresolved NetChoice’s appeal and expedited proceedings.\n\nWe n now affirm in part and reverse in part the district court’s\n\ninjunction.\n\nII\n\nWe have subject-matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C.\n\n§ 1331 and appellate jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C.\n\n§ 1292(a)(1). We review the district court’s denial of a\n\npreliminary injunction for abuse of discretion. X Corp. v.\n\nBonta, 116 F.4th 888, 897 (9th Cir. 2024). A court abuses\n\nits discretion if it commits legal error. See id. We review\n\nNETCHOICE, LLC V. BONTA 15\n\n\nfactual findings for clear error. Am. Beverage Ass’n v. City\n\n& CnCnty. of S.F., 916 F.3d 749, 754 (9th Cir. 2019) (en banc).\n\nTo warrant the “extraordinary remedy” of preliminary\n\nrelief, NetChoice must show that it is likely to succeed on\n\nthe merits, that it is likely to suffer irreparable harm in the\n\ninterim, and that an injunction is both equitable and in the\n\npublic interest. Winter v. Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc., 555\n\nU.S. 7, 20, 24 (2008).\n\nIII\n\n\nNetChoice asks us to reverse the district court in part a and\n\nenjoin the parts of the Act that the district court left in effect.\n\nIt wants that relief not only for its members, but for the world\n\nat large under a facial challenge. Before we address\n\nNetChoice’s arguments, we first focus on the distinction\n\nbetween facial and as-applied challenges.\n\nTo invoke the court’s jurisdiction, NetChoice must\n\nallege a deprivation of a cognizable and “particularized”\n\ninterest. Lujan v. Defs. of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555, 560\n\n(1992). Generally, a plaintiff “must assert his own legal\n\nrights and interests,” and cannot rely on the interests of third\n\nparties. Warth v. Seldin, 422 U.S. 490, 499 (1975). First\n\nAmendment facial challenges provide a narrow exception to\n\nthis rule. Even if a speech regulation is constitutional as\n\napplied to a plaintiff, the plaintiff may challenge the law as\n\nfacially overbroad or vague based on its impact on others’\n\nspeech. See Broadrick v. Oklahoma, 413 U.S. 601, 612\n\n(1973) (overbreadth); United States v. Williams, 553 U.S.\n\n285, 304 (2008) (vagueness).\n\nThe parties do not rigorously delineate between as\u0002\n\napplied and facial challenges. These two analyses overlap,\n\nbut the differences are not limited to the scope of relief. That\n\n16 NETCHOICE, LLC V. BONTA\n\n\nis, a facial challenge is not merely an as-applied challenge\n\n","statutory_number":null,"whole_instrument_recall":"not_established"}rdf:JSON
oa:hasSource
prov:wasDerivedFrom
schema:isPartOf

Related

Errata in its text (1)oa:hasTarget